D&D is generally set in a fantasy medieval world full of castles. Generally the rules describe higher level characters eventually owning castles. DMGR2 is the 2nd edition look at castles and player ownership of them.
Meshing a historical concept with a fantasy world has not proven to be an easy task. Given the availability of magic, there are several real world logistical problems and weaknesses of a castle that can be solved with low level spells (magical aid to construction and creation of food and water to protect against starvation in a siege, to give just two examples). Intelligent use of spellcasters in construction would greatly reduce costs and vulnerabilities of the castle. DMGR2 gives a cursory treatment to magic but generally does not adequately cover the subject of the application of magic to castles.
DMGR2 provides a historical overview of castles that is a bit lacking. It compresses too many details. As a work of history, it is not very good. The material could have been better presented. As a starter to get the DM thinking about the legalities of owning a castle, the material is probably adequate for most campaigns.
Missing from the book is a whole chapter on the application of magic and fantasy to castles. There are hints and acknowledgements here and there in DMGR2 but more comprehensive coverage is needed.
Conclusion: A good starting point for campaigns that are serious about castle building and siege warfare but the lack of discussion of the impact of magic/fantasy on a castle is a major drawback. 2 out of 5 stars.
No comments:
Post a Comment